As NY Lawmakers Mull Budget to Expand Charter Schools, Fears of Federal Cuts May Shift Political Alliances

Arne Duncan Makes Two Big Endorsements in L.A. School Board Race, Throws Support Behind Reformers

Our School’s Too White? Outraged Parents Vow to Lie About Child’s Race to Keep City From Removing Teachers

Ivanka Trump, Betsy DeVos Tout STEM Education to 200 Students at Air & Space Museum

Black Girls 6 Times as Likely to Be Suspended as Whites. ‘Let Her Learn’ Looks to Reverse the Trend

WATCH: 4,000 Kids Take Over NYC’s Radio City Music Hall With America’s Biggest Academic Pep Rally

Where Education Research, Politics & Policy Intersect: 3 States Reveal How Data Help Shape Their ESSA Plans

Tennessee Bets Big on Personalized Learning, Launching Pilot Program & Eyeing Big 2020 Goals

MUST-SEE: School Films Epic 12-Minute ‘Trolls’ Music Video to Lift Spirits of Sick 5-Year-Old Girl

In Uniting Students With Prospective Employers, the Whether Job Search App Wins SXSWedu Tech Competition

More HS Students Are Graduating, but These Key Indicators Prove Those Diplomas Are Worth Less Than Ever

Race & Class: Chicago Schools Sue State, Claim Minority Kids See 78 Cents Per Dollar Sent to White Schools

KIPP v. UFT: Charter Network Sues Union, Arguing It Doesn’t Represent School’s Teachers

Supreme Court Sets New Standard for Special Ed, Unanimously Rejects Minimal School Progress

D.C. Approves ESSA Accountability Plan That Emphasizes Testing Standards & Transparency

Q&A: Why Miami’s Superintendent, Once an Undocumented Immigrant, Is Banning ICE From His Schools

No Warrant, No Way In: NYC to Prevent ICE Agents From Entering Schools Without Warrants

In California, a New Push for Teacher Tenure Reform as State Bill Would Extend Probation to 3 Years

VIDEO REPLAY: The 74 Moderates a Conversation on America’s Misleading Charter School Narrative

In Pitching School Chiefs on ESSA Plans, 2 Congressmen See Wildly Different Futures for U.S. Education

When Zuckerberg Commits Billions for Personalized Learning, He’s Thinking of Programs Like NJ’s ‘Teach to One’

Photo Credit: Getty Images

December 1, 2015

Talking Points

A personalized learning model perfect for new dad Mark Zuckerberg — Teach to One: Math

NJ students already living the personalized learning model $45B Facebook donation will spread worldwide

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and wife, Dr. Priscilla Chan, used the birth of their daughter Max to announce Tuesday they were donating 99 percent of their Facebook shares — a pledge now valued at $45 billion — to essentially remake the world she will inherit, from eradicating disease, to healing conflict to revolutionizing learning.  The tool they see as most effective for realizing every child’s educational potential — regardless of whether they live near a good school — is personalized learning.
“Our generation grew up in classrooms where we all learned the same things at the same pace regardless of our interests or need,” the couple wrote in an open letter to their newborn. “Your generation will set goals for what you want to become — like an engineer, health worker, writer or community leader. You'll have technology that understands how you learn best and where you need to focus. You'll advance quickly in subjects that interest you most, and get as much help as you need in your most challenging areas. You'll explore topics that aren't even offered in schools today.
“Your teachers will also have better tools and data to help you achieve your goals.”
The newly created Chan Zuckerberg Initiative is focusing its early personalized learning efforts in the San Francisco Bay Area but there are other parts of the country where personalized learning has already taken root. In fact, The Seventy Four’s Naomi Nix was reporting on one such program in Elizabeth, New Jersey — a program that’s already been singled out for praise, and granted millions of dollars, by the U.S. Department of Education — in the weeks leading up to the Zuckerberg/Chan announcement that just put the term “personalized learning” on 1.5 billion more lips. Here’s Naomi’s story:
In an iPrep Academy classroom in Elizabeth, New Jersey, an eighth-grader can dabble in high school math on a computer that already knows quite a bit about how he learns. Nearby, a group of seventh-grade students are working together on a class project revolving around a math concept that the eighth-grader may have mastered yesterday or is still struggling with.
That the students are in the same class tackling the same subject at the same time but not at the same level of difficulty or with the same approach is the point of what’s called personalized learning.
The academy, part of the public school system in this industrialized city of 125,000, is one of dozens across the country experimenting with a new personalized learning model called “Teach to One: Math,” which allows students to follow a math curriculum at their own pace, using group work, traditional classroom teaching and virtual tutoring.  
“The students really like it,” said iPrep Principal Lawrence Roodenburg, who first started using the program in 2013. “They are not always doing the same thing.”
Under the program, lesson plans might involve being taught by a teacher in a classroom setting one day, then the next working with a group to practice a concept or tackling  computerized math problems with a virtual tutor one-on-one.
The computerized program tests the students on their mastery of concepts taught during the classroom instruction and can feed them additional lessons on the same concept if they haven’t quite gotten it yet.
The program’s algorithm will also tailor teaching methods to students depending on their past performance — giving them more virtual tutoring if they learn better that way or more collaborative assignments if that approach delivers stronger results.
Teach to One: Math is administered to schools and districts by a New York-based nonprofit, New Classrooms Innovation Partners for Learning, whose motto is “Redesigning the Classroom Experience for Each and Every Student.”
The group draws thousands of lesson plans from a variety of sources — from Kahn Academy, which provides free, short lectures via YouTube videos, to traditional textbooks by educational publishing giant, McGraw-Hill. Those teaching materials are then blended together into New Classrooms’ computer program which assesses kids’ strengths and weaknesses and delivers a ready-made lesson plan tailored for them.
Schools pay $225 per child to use the technology as well as extra fees for any additional support services they want. New Classrooms vets schools that apply to be a partner, including onsite visits for finalists to make sure there is buy-in from the school’s staff.
When new technologies are introduced to schools, they can sometimes be seen as yet another complex technique teachers have to master on top of their already heavy workloads. New Classrooms designed Teach to One with the opposite in mind, aiming to simplify the classroom experience.
“(Teachers) do not have to be overwhelmed by the technology,” New Classrooms co-founder Christopher Rush said. “The technology could free them up to do what they do best.”
iPrep Academy, where the program is being implemented in fifth through eighth grade, says it has seen some positive results. Between the beginning and end of the 2013-14 school year, iPrep students grew 1.75 times more than the national average on Measures of Academic Progress, an assessment created by nonprofit Northwest Evaluation Association which specializes in personalized testing.
This year, the U.S. Department of Education granted the district and New Classrooms $3 million to expand the program to five Elizabeth public schools and to complete a three-year study of its impact being done by the Consortium for Policy Research in Education at Columbia University’s Teachers College.
Teach to One: Math got its start in 2009, when Rush and partner Joel Rose started a similar program at the New York City Department of Education, where three middle schools began experimenting with it. TIME magazine named the initiative one of the top 50 inventions of 2009, calling it “learning for the Xbox generation.”
A study conducted by The Research Alliance for New York City Schools of the first year of the program found it produced mixed results. But a more recent study conducted by Columbia University professor Douglas Ready showed that schools that adopted the Teach to One: Math showed academic gains that were 15 percent above the national average in the first year and 47 percent above the national average in the second year.
Those are the kind of statistics that encourage personalized learning advocates, who argue that abandoning the traditional “one-size-fits-all” approach to teaching will help poor and minority children. But they find themselves at odds with critics who say the method requires schools to over rely on technology when a teacher’s judgement might work better.
“These systems reduce all the richness and complexity of deciding what a learner should be doing to — sometimes literally — a “Next” button,” David Riley, co-founder of electronic textbook company Lumen Learning, wrote in a recent blog post. “As these systems painstakingly work to learn how each student learns, the individual students lose out on the opportunity to learn this for themselves.”
As the debate around personalized learning has evolved, so too has Teach to One: Math.
The program now includes more assignments that require students to spend more time investigating deep, complex problems. Lesson plans also follow a more logical chronology, Rose and Rush said.
Last school year, nine school districts educated more than 6,500 students with the Teach to One: Math model. This year, that number rose to 28 district and charter schools which are educating some 10,000 students in places such as Denver, Colorado, New London, Connecticut and Oakland, California.
Rose and Rush don’t plan to stop there. The future of Teach to One may soon include older and younger students and other types of classwork.
“In the long term, we are excited to expand our reach to elementary, (and) high school as well as other subjects,” Rush said.