DeVos Clashes With Democrats Over Federal Protections in School Choice Budget Proposals

Weekend Education Reads: 12 Worthwhile Links About Students and Schools You May Have Missed

Wisconsin Lawmaker Tells Betsy DeVos That Vouchers Don’t Help Rural Kids. Research Shows He’s Right

You’re Not an ‘Interest Group’ Just Because You Believe School Funding Matters

How 2 Business-Savvy Nonprofits Are Breathing New Life Into Philadelphia’s Struggling Catholic Schools

State of American Pre-K: New Report Shows 1.5 Million Kids (and 1 in 20 3-Year-Olds) Enrolled

Trump Ed Budget Fleshes Out Choice Proposal, Justifies Deep Cuts

Mayoral Control Fight Heats Up: NYS Assembly Gives De Blasio 2 More Years, But Senate Demands More Data on School Spending

The Boys Wouldn’t Listen, So 9-Year-Old Girl Started Her Own Robotics Team — and Won Big

Candidates Are Drawing School Choice Battle Lines in Campaign to Succeed New Jersey Gov. Christie

Start School Later: New Study Shows That More Sunlight Before Classes Improves Test Scores

Facing Pressure From Conservatives, Texas Again Looks to Ban Transgender Bathroom Use

DeVos Emphasizes States’ Prerogative on School Choice, Gives No Details on Federal Expansion

Inside the School Lunch Affordability Gap: Too Affluent for Free Food, Can’t Afford $1.75 Meals

Long-Vacant NYC Courthouse Will Get New Life as Success Academy’s Second High School

1 in 5 Washington State HS Students Considered Suicide, 9% Attempted It, Shocking New Report Finds

Key Congressional Ally Backs Trump Admin’s School Choice Plan

Why the LA School Board Swung Pro-Reform: Did a Late Vote on ‘Charter Killer’ Bill Cost Board Chief His Job?

Federal Judge Denies NYC KIPP School’s Effort to Block Arbitration of Teacher Grievances

New Report Shows NYC’s Alternative to Charter Schools — Supported by De Blasio and UFT — Aren’t Getting Results

The 4 Most Notable Cuts in Trump’s Education Budget — and Why Some Say It’s ‘Dead on Arrival’

Photo Credit: Getty Images

May 18, 2017

Talking Points

School choice, DeVos’s security detail winners in final reported Ed Dept budget

Big cuts to programs for Special Olympics, gifted students, WaPo reports on Trump Ed budget

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

The Washington Post Wednesday afternoon reported on the full details of the Trump administration’s first Education Department budget proposal, expected to be publicly released Tuesday.

The administration in March had put out a “skinny budget” asking for a $9 billion cut to the agency’s roughly $68 billion budget, including eliminating funding for after-school programs and teacher training, while adding new money for school choice programs.

(The 74: Trump Calls for New School Choice Initiatives, Big Cuts to K-12 Budget)

Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is slated to testify at the House Appropriations Committee Wednesday. Trump’s legislative agenda is in question, given the mounting controversy surrounding his presidency, including Wednesday’s appointment by the Justice Department of a special counsel to investigate ties between Russia and the president’s 2016 campaign.

Rick Hess, director of education policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute, bluntly surmised that the sweeping cuts proposed for the education department “don’t matter.”

“He has no juice on Hill. His budget is mega-dead,” Hess tweeted Thursday.

The budget document is an opening bid in what will be a protracted negotiation with Congress over funding for fiscal year 2018, which begins Oct. 1. There is sure to be opposition to much of Trump’s proposal, and at least one key Democrat has already condemned it.

Sen. Patty Murray, the senior Democrat on the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee and the Appropriations subcommittee that deals with education funding, said it “will weaken communities” and confirms that Trump’s and Devos’s “extreme ideological commitment to public school privatization will come at the expense of millions of students around the country.”



DeVos will lay out the specifics of her school choice plan, likely a federal tax-credit scholarship, in a speech to the American Federation for Children, the school choice advocacy group she founded, at its annual conference Monday, Politico reported.

Here, based on the Post’s story, are the budget’s biggest winners and losers:

Winners:

School choice: The budget would provide $500 million for federal charter school grants, $168 million more than this year’s budget, and $250 million in “Education Innovation and Research Grants” that would support expanding and studying private school vouchers. It was not clear how much would be directed toward vouchers versus research, the Post reported.

The Trump administration would also like to devote $1 billion in Title I dollars, which support the education of low-income students, to a new program to be called Furthering Options for Children to Unlock Success. Federal dollars, along with state and local, would follow children as they transfer among public schools, according to the Post.

The Senate rejected that idea in 2015 during debate on what became the Every Student Succeeds Act. Opponents say watering down Title I dollars doesn’t help target pockets of poverty and could send the money, intended for poor children, to wealthy districts.

The $20 million that pays for the Opportunity Scholarship Program in Washington, D.C., the only federally funded voucher program, is included in the bill that allocates funding for D.C. more broadly, not the one covering the Education Department.

DeVos’s security detail: The budget will ask for another $158 million in salaries at the department for student loan servicing, IT security, auditing, investigations, and security for DeVos, even as the department seeks to reduce the roughly 4,000-member agency’s overall workforce by about 150 people.

Previous secretaries have relied on the Education Department’s internal security staff. DeVos, following an early incident in which a protester tried to block her from entering a school, is being protected by the U.S. Marshals Service, the Post reported earlier this year. The Education Department reimburses the marshals service about $1 million a month for that protection, the Post reported in April.

Losers:

Career and technical education: The administration proposes cutting the Perkins program, which gives grants to schools and colleges for career education, by 15 percent, or $168 million.

The House Education and the Workforce Committee Wednesday unanimously passed a bill reauthorizing and updating the Perkins program that authorizes up to $1.13 billion for fiscal 2018, and more in subsequent years.

(The 74: Career and Technical Education Should Be ‘Plan A,’ Foxx Says as House Takes Up Perkins Bill)

Special populations: The budget proposal would also cut smaller programs designed to help specific populations of students, including $12 million for gifted students, $12 million for the Special Olympics, $65 million for Native American and Native Hawaiian students, and $27 million for arts education.

College student borrowers: The administration proposes big shake-ups to federal student loan programs, including eliminating the $700 million Perkins loan program, cutting by nearly half the federal work-study program, and taking steps toward ending the federal subsidies for loans that mean no interest accrues while students are in school.

It also proposes ending public service loan forgiveness, which allows people employed by governments (including teachers) or nonprofits to have federal student loans forgiven after 10 years of on-time, monthly payments.



Office for Civil Rights: The Office for Civil Rights investigates violations of federal protections based on sex, race, and religion, with the number of complaints surging in recent months. The full Trump budget would seek $106.8 million for OCR — equivalent to the first six months of this year, but a decrease from the funding bill passed earlier this month. That would mean a reduction of about 40 jobs, according to the Post.

Disclosure: The Dick & Betsy DeVos Family Foundation previously provided financial support to The 74.