For a Truly Effective School Choice System, Have High-Quality Options in Every Neighborhood

Analysis: NEA Membership Declined in 27 States, and One Where It Grew — NY — Is Anything but Typical

Analysis: No ‘Gold Standard’ in Ed Tech; Continuum of Evidence Needed to Ensure Technology Helps Students

One Dad’s Take: If De Blasio Wants to Oversee NYC’s Schools, He Must Stop Ignoring Students Like My Son

Cisneros: How My West Texas School Elevated Struggling Young Readers (and Their Teachers)

Mikuta: How Trump’s Budget Would Gut Innovations in Teacher Training — Just as Things Are Getting Better

Analysis: Janus Ruling Could Force Unions to Compete for Members

Sahm: NYC Charters Are Leading the Way on School Integration

Brian Pick: How to Help Teachers Get Excited About What They’re Teaching — and Become Better Learners

Report Identifies America’s Best Charter Schools, Where Over 100,000 Kids Are Shown to Be Months Ahead of Peers

Morris & Yoshikawa: The Short-Term Economic Argument for Expanding Access to Preschool

Williams: In Praise of New Jersey, Illinois, Louisiana — 3 States Smartly Using ESSA to Help English Learners

Bailey: Why U.S. Schools Should Look to British Pre-K Standards for Best Early Childhood Ed

Sorensen: How the ‘Friends of the Children’ Mentorship Program Helps Vulnerable Youth Thrive

Rees: The Charter School Movement Meets in Washington, D.C., at a Pivotal Moment

Eden: An Urgent Call for School Transparency — and Giving Parents the Info They Actually Care About

Analysis: Boycotts? Endorsements? Not So Fast — NEA Top Brass Reins in Activist Members

Janus v. AFSCME: Lawyers in Key Union Case Appeal to U.S. Supreme Court for 2017–18 Hearing

Rhim: 4 Ways Philanthropy Can Set the Bar for Special Education in Charter Schools

Analysis: For Ed Tech That Actually Works, Embrace the Science of Learning

Sibilia: Flint’s Water Crisis, Failing Schools, and the Lines That Divide Us

January 21, 2016

Rebecca Sibilia
Rebecca Sibilia

Rebecca Sibilia is the founder and CEO of EdBuild, an education reform startup seeking to redesign school finance. Prior to starting EdBuild, Sibilia served as the chief operating officer and vice president for fiscal strategy at StudentsFirst.

Rebecca Sibilia is the founder and CEO of EdBuild, an education reform startup seeking to redesign school finance. Prior to starting EdBuild, Sibilia served as the chief operating officer and vice president for fiscal strategy at StudentsFirst.
Talking Points

.@RebeccaSibilia on Flint's water crisis, failing schools and how the system is rigged against America's poor

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

“The impact of the problem has just exploded, but there's always been a problem with lead poisoning and poor kids." (Ann Richards, a senior communications officer for the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation)
The toxic water scandal now unfolding in Flint, Michigan is a large-scale human-rights crisis happening in our own backyard, and it’s particularly devastating for the children living within the geographic area. And I’ve found that — as someone whose work is principally focused on the inequities of and created by our education system — there are striking parallels between the ways governments neglect their poorest citizens, whether in infrastructure or public education.
What’s happening in Flint did not happen overnight. This crisis has been building for months, and political leaders have repeatedly failed to act on it. And – as with too many of our schools — every day that goes by without correcting the current conditions is one more day of injustice to children. Exposure to high levels of lead and other contaminants in drinking water can have long-term consequences for children, impacting their ability to learn and function for years.
From my perspective, the harm being done in Flint is most frustrating because it reflects so clearly the historical and systemic lack of access to opportunity afforded to those in poverty.  Whether the public good is safe, clean drinking water, or a high-quality, rigorous, public education, this issue clearly illustrates the failure of the local, state, and federal government to provide for its constituents. And in both cases, when government fails to deliver it utterly neglects the needs of the poorest among us, and creates conditions in which they are not able — in a sense, not even allowed — to escape.
Consider: The poorest of Flint’s residents are now effectively imprisoned by our collective failure to solve their water problem. Most cannot afford to move — not only because the homes of these already-struggling residents have plummeted in value, but because federal law prohibits selling a lead-contaminated home without disclosing its problems, and no Flint homeowner can afford to clean up the government’s mess. This means that, though Flint residents are, of course, frustrated and would like to move, it’s impossible for them to escape without either breaking the law or breaking the bank.
Likewise, parents and children across the country are imprisoned by the often-arbitrary borders of their school districts. Governments literally draw district boundaries around poor communities, and then fail to effectively serve children in low-income districts. And they prohibit those children from crossing district lines in pursuit of a better education. Flint parents could dare to enroll their children in the higher-performing schools in Grand Blanc — a tony suburb right next to Flint — but they would have to declare a false address and risk criminal prosecution.  Instead of being able to send their kids to great schools, they’re fenced into failing schools by the arbitrary and inequitable process through which school districts are defined and funded.
This correlation isn’t coincidental; it’s systemic. This is about the way governments choose to treat communities; the way services look very different across municipal and district borders. It’s a disturbing reminder of the disparities across the lines that divide us.
The Flint water crisis is about the lack of agency afforded to those in poverty, and the government’s unwillingness to allow people to escape its own failings.
We should all be outraged by this.
So I urge my colleagues fighting for radical change in our public schools to take up the call to action in Flint. This is an opportunity for those of us devoted to social justice to join forces against the structural inequities that deny our neediest and most vulnerable citizens the most critical services for public welfare.