Analysis: The NEA’s 5 Financially Shakiest States

Bradford: Teachers Unions Exploited Ed Reform Split Over DeVos While Never Losing Focus

Essay: Running for Change, South Dakota High Schooler Protests Pipeline, Meets the President (Twice)

Allen: Advice to Secretary DeVos — Lean In, Be Bold, Talk About Power, and Rethink Twitter

Analysis: Was Hillary’s Union Support Limited to (Some of) the Public Sector?

Barber: Transformation — The Time Is Now

KIPP Leaders: 4 Critical Areas Secretary DeVos Should Focus on to Ensure All Students Succeed

Opinion: Now More Than Ever, Diverse Charter Schools Are Essential

Whitmire: Dear Secretary DeVos, If You Want to Grow Great Charter Schools, Do This, Not That

Sahm: Found in Yonkers

Hernandez: DeVos Should Tell Her Critics All Kids Deserve School Choice — Just Like Theirs Have

Marnie Kaplan: Sometimes Government IS the Solution — Reauthorizing Head Start, 10 Years Later

Analysis: The One Senator Teachers Unions Might Have Swayed on DeVos Is the One Who Couldn’t Vote ‘No’

Analysis: Facing Threats, Can Public-Sector Unions Learn From the Demise of Industrial Workers?

Bradford: Dangerous for Charter Advocates to Embrace Elizabeth Warren and Trash School Vouchers

Eden: When the New York Times’s Reporting on DeVos and Detroit Charters Looks Like ‘Alternative Facts’

Open Letter: What the NAACP Should Know About Florida’s Charter Schools Ahead of Tonight’s Orlando Hearing

Analysis: The Strange Disappearance of 69,000 AFT Members

Ashley Berner and Charles L. Glenn: America’s Muslim Schools and the Common Good

Whitmire: Welcome to the Trump Presidency — and the Hazy New Battle Lines of the Education Debate

Opinion: Why I’m Taking My Child Out of Our Renewal School

Photo Credit: Getty Images

February 15, 2017

Lucy Garner
Lucy Garner

Lucy Garner is a parent at Wadleigh Secondary School for the Performing & Visual Arts in Harlem.

Lucy Garner is a parent at Wadleigh Secondary School for the Performing & Visual Arts in Harlem.
Talking Points

A parent explains why she’s opting out of #RenewalSchools @NYCSchools

Zero students test proficient in math, worse than before #RenewalSchools started

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

When I found out my child would be attending Wadleigh Secondary School for the Performing & Visual Arts, one of New York City’s “Renewal Schools,” I was hopeful. I went to Wadleigh when I was a girl; I knew it was struggling, but I thought the new focus and resources that came with the Renewal program meant it could only get better. Unfortunately, even with the new label, the school keeps failing its students.

When he announced Renewal Schools in November 2014, Mayor Bill de Blasio made them sound as if they were at the very center of his education platform. He promised that the program would turn around chronically struggling schools.

But in Harlem, where I live, and in other neighborhoods like mine, nothing has changed. The schools are still not making the progress that parents expect and need to see. It’s clear to me that politicians like the mayor won’t do enough to shake up a very broken system; instead, the kids where I live get stuck with the same failed experience every year.

Unfortunately, Wadleigh Secondary School is a perfect example of what’s wrong. On the past two state tests, not a single student was proficient in math. The numbers have actually gotten worse since Renewal began. For that reason, I don’t call it a real turnaround plan, and neither do other parents — which is why enrollment has dropped 40 percent since the mayor took office.

My child tells me school is like a roller coaster. She works hard but keeps coming up short in algebra. In her English class, she was on the honor roll last semester but got sick, missed a few days, and her teacher removed her from the honor roll. What kind of message does that send to a kid who’s really trying? I feel as if none of her teachers are stepping up to truly help the kids based on their learning and personality needs and no one is holding the teachers and other staff accountable.

To make matters worse, my child has been bullied constantly since starting at Wadleigh. I have spoken to the principal on several occasions, but no one has taken any action.

I won’t give up. I fight every day to make sure that my child receives a quality education. I try to stay in constant contact with her teachers. But the school isn’t organized to provide the instruction she needs to be prepared for college by the time she graduates.

Every child is entitled to a quality education, but the system isn’t serving my community or my child. That’s why I applied for a spot at a charter school — I won’t let her be just another statistic. The charter we’re on the waiting list for provides real hope, opportunity, and results. Mr. Mayor: You can give a school any fancy title you want, but if you don’t make the necessary changes, another generation of children will suffer.

Lucy Garner is a parent at Wadleigh Secondary School for the Performing & Visual Arts in Harlem.