Essay: Running for Change, South Dakota High Schooler Protests Pipeline, Meets the President (Twice)

Allen: Advice to Secretary DeVos — Lean In, Be Bold, Talk About Power, and Rethink Twitter

Opinion: Why I’m Taking My Child Out of Our Renewal School

Analysis: Was Hillary’s Union Support Limited to (Some of) the Public Sector?

Barber: Transformation — The Time Is Now

KIPP Leaders: 4 Critical Areas Secretary DeVos Should Focus on to Ensure All Students Succeed

Opinion: Now More Than Ever, Diverse Charter Schools Are Essential

Whitmire: Dear Secretary DeVos, If You Want to Grow Great Charter Schools, Do This, Not That

Sahm: Found in Yonkers

Hernandez: DeVos Should Tell Her Critics All Kids Deserve School Choice — Just Like Theirs Have

Marnie Kaplan: Sometimes Government IS the Solution — Reauthorizing Head Start, 10 Years Later

Analysis: The One Senator Teachers Unions Might Have Swayed on DeVos Is the One Who Couldn’t Vote ‘No’

Analysis: Facing Threats, Can Public-Sector Unions Learn From the Demise of Industrial Workers?

Bradford: Dangerous for Charter Advocates to Embrace Elizabeth Warren and Trash School Vouchers

Eden: When the New York Times’s Reporting on DeVos and Detroit Charters Looks Like ‘Alternative Facts’

Open Letter: What the NAACP Should Know About Florida’s Charter Schools Ahead of Tonight’s Orlando Hearing

Analysis: The Strange Disappearance of 69,000 AFT Members

Ashley Berner and Charles L. Glenn: America’s Muslim Schools and the Common Good

Whitmire: Welcome to the Trump Presidency — and the Hazy New Battle Lines of the Education Debate

Robinson: Obama Redefined School Reform for Democrats

Opinion: Reimagining School Choice Debates

Photo Credit: Getty Images

December 15, 2016

Ashley Berner
Ashley Berner

Ashley Berner is the deputy director of the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy. A longer version of this piece may be found on the Institute’s website. Palgrave Macmillan released Berner’s new book, Pluralism and American Public Education: No One Way to School, in November 2016.

Ashley Berner is the deputy director of the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy. A longer version of this piece may be found on the Institute’s website. Palgrave Macmillan released Berner’s new book, Pluralism and American Public Education: No One Way to School, in November 2016.
Talking Points

Defending “school choice” is a modern challenge; in the past, lots of different kinds of schools co-existed

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Should our school systems be uniform or plural? This question lies at the heart of school-choice debates in the United States. Most democracies — including the Netherlands, England, Sweden and Canada — fund diverse schools as a matter of principle. Educational pluralism is embedded in nations as different as Australia, India and Singapore. These countries do not cast common purpose to the wind; they regulate their schools’ curricula, admissions processes and hiring protocols. Education is considered a public good that may be delivered by civic organizations and the state alike.

School systems in the United States used to be plural, too. Counties and municipalities levied taxes to fund Catholic and Jewish schools alongside schools that were Protestant in name or in spirit. Anti-Catholic, anti-immigration nativists put a stop to this in the late 19th century and gave us uniform school systems instead. Recent diversification in the form of charters, tax credits, vouchers and education savings accounts are a return to the norm we once embraced and which many democracies take for granted.

Battles about the underlying structure of our school systems are thus not only political and legal but also cultural, fought within the framework bequeathed to us by the 19th century. The very term “public school” triggers images and expectations — a neighborhood common school — against which all other models must justify themselves.

As a result, we bury ourselves in disputes over whose charter school research to trust or whether the “Catholic school effect” is real. This unhealthy competition is an unfortunate by-product of our cultural default to the common-school model. Embracing a more capacious understanding of “public education” would free us to strive for excellence for all students, wherever they go to school.

To diversify the system so completely that it changed the way we imagine public schooling would challenge both ends of the political spectrum. Should Montessori, Muslim and Jewish schools be funded alongside district schools? This is anathema to those who believe only the state can deliver democratic education. Should the government mandate school inspections and state assessments to ensure high-quality instruction in participating private schools? Such supervision goes against the grain of libertarianism and local control. Both points of view are strong in American education, and navigating between them will not be easy.

But it can be done. After all, the cultural and political forces that moved our schools toward uniformity in the 19th century are moving in the opposite direction now. And while many democracies pluralized public education in the 19th century, the number of countries that support diverse schools continues to grow.

A good example: the Canadian province of Alberta. In the 1990s, Alberta changed the structure, content and funding mechanisms of public education. The province centralized funding, making schools less reliant upon property tax values; expanded educational options, allowing funds to flow not only to Jewish and Catholic schools but also to Inuit and even homeschooling families; and required all schools to teach an academically strong core curriculum. Alberta’s school system became one of the world’s most equitable and academically successful. A grand bargain of this kind is possible here — and could, over time, establish a new framework for public education.

Ashley Berner is deputy director of the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy and assistant professor at the School of Education. Palgrave Macmillan released her book, Pluralism and American Public Education: No One Way to School, in November.