10 Kids + 1 Teacher = The Smallest School in the Tiniest District in America’s Least Populated State

Hard to Game, Easy to Use: Chronic Absenteeism Gains Ground as New ESSA Measure of Student Success

The 74 Interview: L.A. Education Activist Yolie Flores on Schools, Politics, and Why She’s Running for Congress

No Birds No Bees: Texas Students Rarely Get Quality Sex Ed Despite High Teen Birth Rates

Study: Weakening Tenure in Louisiana May Have Caused Thousands of Teachers to Quit

Obama-Era Protections for Transgender Students to Be Revoked, Gavin Grimm Supreme Court Case at Risk

‘We Must Draw a Line in the Sand’: Inside Nevada’s New Campaign to Rescue Failing Schools

Suburban Districts Cry Foul As Connecticut Governor Looks to Shift State Funds to Poorer Urban Schools

‘A Huge Win’: Washington State Charter School Supporters Celebrate Major Courtroom Victory

CogniToys Dino Can Answer Kids’ Questions All Day Long, in and out of the Classroom

At Philadelphia’s Mastery Charter Network, Culture Is Key to Turning Around Failing Schools

WATCH: Understand Open Enrollment in 120 Seconds or Less

Elementary Schools Across America Celebrate Their First 100 Days of School With Style on Social Media

How’s Your School Culture? ESSA Says It’s Important, but Only 1 in 3 Students Nationwide Think It’s Good

Opinion: In Search of America’s Hidden Figures

The Certification Maze: Why Teachers Who Cross State Lines Can’t Find Their Way Back to the Classroom

Clean Sweep: How Washers in Schools Boost Attendance and Improve Day-to-Day Life for the Neediest Students

In Missouri, The Stars Align for School Choice

Governor’s Pick for New Hampshire Schools Chief Divides State, Echoes DeVos Controversy

As Immigration Battles Heat Up Across the U.S., California District Faces Its Own Refugee Crisis

Indiana Flashback: New to Team Trump, Education Secretary Pick DeVos Has Long Been on Team Pence

Photo Credit: Getty Images

November 23, 2016

Talking Points

Pence has long supported school choice programs backed by ed reformer DeVos and her foundation

Vouchers and charter schools are top priorities of the VP-elect and the new ed secretary nominee

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Education secretary nominee Betsy DeVos wasn’t a vocal supporter of Donald Trump during his bid for the White House. But with Vice President–elect Mike Pence on Team Trump, DeVos wasn’t a terribly surprising pick.
For decades, DeVos has encouraged states to implement school-choice programs and shelled out money to help them do it. That includes Indiana, where Pence, as governor, pursued many of the choice initiatives supported by the Republican power broker and by the American Federation for Children, which she founded and chairs.
DeVos’s involvement in the education reform movement dates back decades. She and her husband, Dick, played a key role in 1993 in getting the state of Michigan to pass its first charter school law. In 2010, she founded the federation to lobby in states around the country for voucher programs that enable low-income students to pay for private school with tax dollars.
Pence was a strong proponent of school vouchers when he served in the House of Representatives from 2001 to 2013, supporting the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program — the only federally funded school voucher system in the nation.
He brought that commitment to vouchers home when he became governor of Indiana in 2013, pushing to dramatically expand the program for low- and middle-income families, in both funding and eligibility. By 2016, Indiana had the largest school voucher system in the country, with more than 30,000 students participating in the program to attend private and religious schools. About 60 percent of Indiana students qualify for the state dollars, which average about $4,000 apiece per year. Research on how vouchers affect student outcomes, including in Indiana, is mixed.
Pence also created a $50 million low-interest-loan program to promote charter school expansion in Indiana and approved rules to prevent low-performing charters from escaping closure or skirting accountability.
An early adopter of the Common Core, Indiana in 2014 became the first state to drop the standards in favor of new benchmarks for grades K-12. States’ rights advocates and right-wing activists opposed the standards on the grounds that they had been drawn up without sufficient local input. The replacement standards, however, drew criticism from the opponents, who argued that they closely resembled the Common Core and were simply a “rebranded” version.
On Wednesday, after her nomination was announced, DeVos tweeted that she is not a supporter of the Common Core and wrote on her website that the standards had become a “federalized boondoggle.” However, she does serve on Jeb Bush’s Foundation for Excellence in Education (ExcelInEd), an education-reform group that promotes the state standards.
When Trump announced Pence as his running mate in July, DeVos and the federation were quick to offer praise, calling Pence a “longtime champion for educational choice” who has a “proven record of accomplishment when it comes to advancing educational choice and innovation.” Earlier this month, he shared a table at a Republican Governors Association event with DeVos, who previously served as a Republican national committeewoman and as chairwoman of the Michigan Republican Party.
In 2013, Pence was the keynote speaker at the AFC’s National Policy Summit. He said in his address that he supported school choice “before it was cool” and that options like charters and vouchers are “the right idea because parents want it, students’ futures depend on it, the market demands it.”


Leading up to the event, DeVos called Pence “one of the most vocal and committed advocates in the fight to provide all children with the opportunity to receive a better education through educational options.”
In his keynote, Pence spoke about a 2013 Indiana Supreme Court decision that upheld the state’s voucher program, which then-Gov. Mitch Daniels had signed into law in 2011. Pence called the court’s verdict, which ruled that the voucher system did not violate a state constitutional prohibition on public funding for religious programs, the “largest victory for school choice in the history of our state.”

The Dick & Betsy DeVos Family Foundation provides funding to The 74, and the site’s Editor-in-Chief, Campbell Brown, sits on the American Federation for Children’s board of directors, which was formerly chaired by Betsy DeVos. Brown played no part in the reporting or editing of this article. The American Federation for Children also sponsored The 74’s 2015 New Hampshire education summit.

The 74 is supported by donations from foundations, corporate sponsors and individuals. Our reporters play no role in cultivating financial relationships with any of our contributors. Donors do not dictate editorial content and understand that The 74 may publish content that does not reflect their views or preferences.