Mehlhorn: The Top Court in CA Declines Teacher Tenure Case, as Dissenting Justices Write for History

Analysis — When Teachers Unions Become The Man: Why Union Employees Are Fighting for Better Contracts

Matus: John Oliver’s Charter School Critique and the Left’s Growing Divide Over School Choice

Smith: A Few Thoughts About John Oliver’s Bleak, Unrepresentative Sample of Public Charter Schools

Jeremiah Grace: Connecticut Charter Schools Celebrate ‘Miraculous’ 20th Anniversary

Analysis: Act Locally, Think Nationally — The NEA’s Plan to Capture America’s Hearts & Minds

Cynthia Tucker Haynes: How a Backlash Against Elites Became an Attack on School Standards

Brown: Mayor De Blasio’s Shameful Claim That NYC Students Only Perform Well Thanks to Test Prep

Teaching Trump: How Do You Talk to Students About ‘Character’ When Donald Keeps Rewriting the Rules?

John Deasy: Bridging the Chasm Between the World and Me — My Promise to Ta-Nehisi Coates

Campbell Brown: NYC Charter Schools — Surging Parent Demand vs. Reluctant City Leaders

Analysis: Los Angeles Teachers Head Is Ready to Incite A ‘State Crisis’ If Union Demands Are Not Met

Cunningham: Why True Progressives Should Push Massachusetts to Lift Cap on Public Charter Schools

Sedlis: Dissatisfied Parents, Weak Renewal Schools…NYC Has Some Work to Do For Students

Opinion: What Conservative Education Reformers Have in Common with Black Lives Matter

Analysis: How the 2016 Republican Party Platform Guts Title IX Enforcement for Sexual Assault Victims

Analysis: 3 Things America’s Biggest Teachers Union Will Expect From a Clinton White House

Explainer: Why Test Glitches Are a Much Bigger Problem Than You Think

Tucker: Hoping Clinton Rekindles the Spirit that Pioneered an Innovative Preschool Program

Peter Cunningham: And the Next Education Secretary Is…

Kingsland: What Happens to Teachers When Charter Schools Come to Town? A New Orleans Case Study

February 22, 2016

Neerav Kingsland
Neerav Kingsland

Neerav Kingsland is the CEO of the Hastings Fund. He was previously the CEO of New Schools for New Orleans (NSNO), where he managed the organization toward achieving its goals in the areas of citywide strategic leadership, school development, and human capital. He is routinely invited to speak about the impact of New Orleans school reforms.

Neerav Kingsland is the CEO of the Hastings Fund. He was previously the CEO of New Schools for New Orleans (NSNO), where he managed the organization toward achieving its goals in the areas of citywide strategic leadership, school development, and human capital. He is routinely invited to speak about the impact of New Orleans school reforms.
Talking Points

.@NeeravKingsland on new research in New Orleans that shows what happens to teachers when charters come to town

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Education reform affects both children and adults: it changes how children learn and how adults work.

In hot spots for reform, such as New Orleans and Newark, observers have expressed concerns that reform efforts might damage communities by firing local veteran educators and replacing them with young outsiders.

Even if children benefit, they say, perhaps communities, as a whole, will suffer.  

Previously, there was little data to address such fears. But fortunately, researchers at Tulane University have finally conducted research on both issues and, for New Orleans, we now have a much better understanding of how much things have improved for students — as well as how adults were impacted by these reforms.

In New Orleans, the academic gains have been immense. High school graduation rates are up over twenty points, and the proficiency gap with the remainder of the state has been nearly closed. Tulane researchers conducted a rigorous analysis of student achievement growth and noted: “we are not aware of any other districts that have made such large improvements in such a short time.”


Video Profile: 10 Years After Katrina, the Rebirth of New Orleans’ Schools

In New Orleans, the changes in the composition of the teaching force have also been significant. Here’s a quick overview of the research on how the teaching force in New Orleans changed over the last decade:

  • The teaching force went from 71% African-American to 49% African-American.
  • The percentage of teachers who graduated from a New Orleans college went from 60% to 34%.
  • The percentage of teachers with less than five years of experience went from 33% to 54%.

All of which begs the question, were the student achievement gains worth the loss in jobs for the African-American community?

Ultimately, how one answers this question will have as much to do with values as data, but one way to further understand the issue is by looking at the number of jobs impacted, rather than changes in percentages. There are roughly 2,750 teachers in New Orleans. Had the previous teaching composition held constant, the number of teaching jobs held by African-Americans would have been 1,950 rather than the estimated 1,350.  

So there are about 600 less teaching jobs held by African-Americans today.

Now consider: There are about 180,000 African-American adults in New Orleans. That means 0.3% of African-American adults have been affected by the changes in the composition of the New Orleans teaching force.

From a jobs perspective, the reforms have not gutted the African-American middle class. Teaching, while an important profession, is only a small part of the city’s economy. But of course, numbers aren’t everything. The whitening of historically black institutions can have a larger impact on a community than the numbers might indicate.

Still, wherever one ends on the issue, the numbers seem to show that the most extreme worries of community harm have not actually occurred.

But even if one concludes that past reforms were worth it (which I do), there is still cause for concern. Research demonstrates, and common sense confirms, that students of colors benefit from role models who share their backgrounds. If the trend in racial composition of the teaching force continues, New Orleans students may lack adequate role models.

Furthermore, given the risks in implicit racial bias in hiring through professional and social networks, the whitening of the teaching force may lead to the exclusion of effective teachers of colors.

Lastly, importing talent may be an unsustainable strategy. At some point, a new city will become the epicenter of reform, and the pipeline for teachers outside New Orleans may be further squeezed.

As the Tulane researchers note in their report, local education leaders are worried about the issue. And they are trying to come up with innovative solutions to localize and diversify teacher pipelines.

You can read about some New Orleans pilots here, including a program called Brothers Empowered to Teach, which aims to increase the number of men of color who enter the teaching profession.

But, as of yet, the issue remains unsolved. And, given the racial distrust that still often divides the city’s leadership, solutions may be difficult to come by.

All of which gets to the core issue of charter school growth: over the long-term, who gets hired is much more consequential than who gets fired. In most cities, the rate of charter school growth is less than the rate of average annual teacher turnover. As such, managing natural attrition in an effective manner can prevent most teachers from being negatively impacted by charter growth.

It is who the charters hire that will, overtime, determine whether or not schools are staffed by effective educators of color.

As such, diverse coalitions will be needed to develop solutions, which could include supporting more African-American entrepreneurs to launch and scale charters schools; charter schools partnering with historically black colleges and universities; and local colleges of education placing their students in residencies at high-performing charter schools.

The question is not whether or not education reform – and the growth of high-quality charters schools – will destroy communities. The opposite will almost always be true. Great schools are the foundation of great communities.

But for great schools to sustain themselves, they will need to be led and staffed by great educators of color.