Updated Aug. 9
After telling school officials she was raped in the band room, Rachel Bradshaw-Bean was punished. Instead of receiving protection from leaders at her Texas high school, she was kicked out and shipped off to an alternative school
— alongside the boy she said attacked her.
In California, 13-year-old Seth Walsh killed himself after telling classmates he was gay. Walsh faced two years of relentless and escalating harassment after coming out, investigators said, but school officials failed to address the abuse
until it was too late. In 2010, he hanged himself.
In both of those cases, the K-12 school districts reached agreements with the U.S. Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights, after federal investigators found that local education officials had flubbed their obligation to protect students from gender-based violence under Title IX, which prohibits sex discrimination in schools. In each case, district leaders promised they’d create new school policies to better protect student safety.
Adele Kimmel is banking on a similar outcome for her client. A Washington, D.C.–based senior attorney at Public Justice, Kimmel has been representing sexual-violence victims for several years, including a young Georgia woman who also faced retaliation for reporting an attack
. Inside a Gwinnett County high school’s newsroom, Kimmel said, a male classmate coerced the young woman into performing oral sex. After she reported the incident to school officials, she was suspended for engaging in sexual acts on campus. But first, Kimmel said, educators grilled her client with bone-chilling questions: “What were you wearing?” “Why didn’t you scream louder?”
Gwinnett County Public Schools is currently one of 137 K-12 school districts under investigation by the Office for Civil Rights for 154 Title IX sexual violence complaints, according to a spreadsheet, dated Aug. 2, that the department provided to The 74. The pending investigations — against public districts, private institutions, and charter school networks in 37 states and the District of Columbia — stretch back as far as December 2010. On the university level, the office currently has 350 investigations pending at 246 postsecondary institutions, according to an Education Department spreadsheet also dated Aug. 2.
Pending investigations at 137 school districts
Click on the points for details about each open case.
Source: U.S. Department of Education
And though Kimmel suspects the investigation against Gwinnett County is nearing a close, she said the outcome is up in the air as Education Secretary Betsy DeVos considers highly contested changes to the way the federal government holds schools accountable for sexual harassment and student assaults. The closely watched debate has converged around sexual violence on college campuses, but it could also have huge ramifications for students in K-12 schools, which, advocates say, have long struggled to protect victims from harm.
“What you see most commonly is that colleges are far ahead of K-12 schools in the development of their sexual-misconduct policies and procedures, their training, and their education of staff and students, making sure that students know who the Title IX coordinator is,” Kimmel said. “My concern is that — with the changes that seem to be coming from the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights — K-12 schools are going to fall even further behind in terms of Title IX compliance.”
An overlooked problem
Victims of sexual assault on college campuses found a national platform as the Obama administration placed a clear focus on Title IX enforcement, most notably for articulating the evidentiary standard for findings of wrongdoing in campus sexual-violence cases. While K-12 schools have largely been left out of the building debate, the Office for Civil Rights has seen a surge in Title IX complaints
against these schools similar to those targeted at colleges and universities.
Following a series of July listening sessions
with victims of sexual violence, students who say they were unfairly punished under Title IX, and education leaders, DeVos is contemplating a philosophical and practical shift at the department’s civil rights division, which the new administration plans to revive
as a “neutral, impartial, investigative agency.” In resolving sexual-violence investigations, DeVos said
, “a system without due process ultimately serves no one in the end.”
“There are some things that are working. There are many things that are not working well,” DeVos told reporters
. “We need to get this right.”
Obama-era Title IX guidance has been a thorn for Republican lawmakers and advocates who have alleged — including in lawsuits
— that the former administration stripped due-process rights from students accused of sexual harassment and assault. At the heart of that complaint is a 2011 “Dear Colleague” letter
that urged colleges and K-12 schools to better investigate reports of sexual violence, specifying that educators “must use a preponderance of the evidence standard” in campus investigations, rather than a more rigorous “clear and convincing” standard. Advocates for sexual assault victims argue that the “preponderance of the evidence” standard is used to adjudicate civil rights claims.
Secretary Betsy DeVos holds a press conference at the Education Department in July after hosting a series of meetings with victims of sexual violence, students who say they were unfairly punished under Title IX, and education leaders.
Photo: Getty Images
Under President Trump, however, advocates for sexual-assault victims are on the defensive. As federal education officials weigh revising Title IX guidance, Kimmel worries that DeVos and Candice Jackson, acting head of OCR, have subscribed to “rape myths.” Her confidence in OCR as an avenue for civil rights relief, she said, has waned.
A day before meeting with stakeholders about the department’s Title IX guidance, Jackson told The New York Times the process for investigating student sexual-violence allegations has not been “fairly balanced between the accused victim and the accused student,” and that some students have been unfairly implicated.
“The accusations — 90 percent of them — fall into the category of ‘we were both drunk, we broke up, and six months later I found myself under a Title IX investigation because she just decided that our last sleeping together was not quite right,” Jackson said, later issuing an apology
and calling the statements “flippant.”
Jayne Ellspermann, a former principal in Florida, acknowledged that while K-12 leaders across the country have an obligation to ensure students are safe on school grounds, not all districts are on the same level. Some have robust supports with clear guidelines and procedures, she said, but in other communities “this situation might not have ever occurred and they don’t have a framework to work with.”
She said federal oversight is beneficial for communities lacking strong procedures, but “the local level is the most appropriate” place for situations to be handled.
“We need to trust the schools and law enforcement and the local social service agencies to do their jobs to support students and schools in situations like this,” said Ellspermann, who recently completed a one-year stint as president of the National Association of Secondary School Principals.
In response to potential policy shifts under the DeVos administration, Ellspermann said it’s important to “to look at different procedures and ensure that they are appropriate for the current day and time, and so I am open to looking at different procedures that we have in place to see whether or not they are necessary on many levels.”
Gwinnett County Public Schools officials didn’t respond to requests for comment. Naomi Gittins, managing director of the National School Boards Association, and Phillip Hartley, its vice chair, were listed among those who attended a Title IX listening session with DeVos, but neither responded to requests for comment. Francisco Negron, the group’s general counsel, was traveling outside the country and could not be reached.
After the Obama administration released its 2011 guidance, Negron raised several concerns, joining the ranks of some college officials who have argued
that it’s vague and inconsistent. The department, he told Education Week
, needed to better clarify when an off-campus incident should prompt district intervention.
“Say the allegations haven’t been proven,” Negron said at the time. “It’s not clear from the department’s guidance what the district’s responsibility would be.”
An obligation to help
The prevalence of child sexual abuse is difficult to pinpoint because victims often do not report the attack, though studies have shown
that about 20 percent of girls and 5 percent of boys are victims of sexual abuse. In fact, 44 percent
of attacks take place before the victim enrolls in college. And children who experience sexual violence are nearly 14 times
as likely as those who don’t to experience rape or attempted rape in their first year of college, according to the National Center for Victims of Crime.
More than half of attacks occur at or near the victim’s home, and 8 percent
take place on school property, according to the Rape, Abuse, and Incest National Network.
In the first year of Obama’s presidency, in 2009, the Office for Civil Rights received just 11 Title IX sexual-violence complaints against K-12 schools, according to federal figures
. By the end of his term, in 2016, that number jumped up to 83, totaling 265 K-12 complaints over the eight-year period.
Additionally, officials at the Office for Civil Rights resolved 371 sexual-violence complaints against K-12 schools and colleges, including a compliance review of California’s West Contra Costa Unified School District, where federal officials found sexually harassing behavior among students “permeated the district’s elementary and secondary schools” following a 2009 high school gang rape.
Despite the sharp increase in complaints, the numbers don’t indicate a surge in sexual violence, Catherine Lhamon, the Education Department’s assistant secretary of civil rights under Obama, told The 74 in June
. Rather, she said, the increase shows people saw OCR as an avenue for relief. Nationally, the rate of sexual assault
and rape has fallen more than 60 percent in the last two decades. Although research has varied, studies suggest
that between 2 percent and 8 percent of sexual assault complaints are false.
“Also, there was a galvanizing movement around the country of securing change on those topics, and so it prompted more people to feel safe coming forward,” Lhamon said. “Over too many decades, sexual harassment and sexual violence have been categories of shame for people who have experienced them, and it has been hard for them to come forward.”
In the late 1990s, the U.S. Supreme Court issued two rulings
that set standards for when schools and colleges can be held liable under Title IX for failing to prevent student-on-student and teacher-on-student sexual harassment and assault. Yet more than 80 percent of high school guidance counselors
feel ill-equipped to address reports of abuse, according to Break the Cycle, an organization that addresses teen dating violence.
“I wish I was seeing a trend where schools are becoming increasingly knowledgeable and better trained in the K-12 setting, but I’m not,” said Michigan-based attorney Monica Beck of the Fierberg National Law Group. “I think a lot of people don’t understand the prevalence of sexual assault in this country’s schools.”
Along with defining the evidentiary standard, Obama-era guidance documents directed districts to hire Title IX coordinators to oversee compliance, promptly investigate and resolve complaints, and provide reasonable accommodations to victims so they can pursue an education in a safe environment. Failure to comply, the department noted, could cost a district its federal funds — an extreme measure that’s never been used against either a K-12 school or a college or university.
Generally, districts sign voluntary resolution agreements
and promise changes if the Office for Civil Rights finds they aren’t compliant with the law, as was the case with Rachel Bradshaw-Bean’s district in Henderson, Texas, and Seth Walsh’s district in Tehachapi, California.
In the past few months, the Trump administration has already shown that Obama-era guidance letters are easily reversed. In February, the Departments of Education and Justice rescinded
an Obama-era “Dear Colleague” letter that said Title IX prohibits discrimination based on gender identity, not just a student’s sex at birth.
“Policies imposed through ‘Dear Colleagues’ and guidances may be reversed summarily by a new administration,” Jonathan Adler, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University who is critical of the Obama-era guidance, told The 74 last year
. “That was always a risk of trying to proceed this way.”
Former Obama education officials maintain, however, that reversing guidance letters won’’t change the protections and legal obligations laid out in Title IX.
Even as the Georgia student waits for the Education Department to reach a verdict in her case, her reporting has already prompted changes in Gwinnett County schools, Kimmel said. Unlike before, for example, the district has a website that identifies its Title IX coordinators and district policies. A ruling could force additional changes.
After filing a complaint with the office, investigators launched a compliance review, which looks at three years of district complaint records to determine whether systemic civil rights violations existed.
“Part of the reason that students will file these complaints is that they’re looking to make changes so nobody else goes through what they did,” Kimmel said.
Under DeVos, however, the Office for Civil Rights has already laid out plans
to roll back that review process, according to an internal memo
sent by Jackson and obtained by ProPublica.
In a statement, an Education Department spokesman said the office will apply a “systemic” or “class action” approach to investigations if a complainant raises widespread issues or the department determines such issues exist through conversations with the complainant.
In June, Jackson told university attorneys
the expansive approach created a backlog of pending cases, according to Inside Higher Ed, noting several times that “justice delayed is justice denied.” On average, the office takes 703 days
to resolve a complaint.
Transparency in sexual-assault investigations could also be on the way out. In 2014, the Education Department began releasing a spreadsheet of institutions under investigation for Title IX violations to highlight the prevalence of sexual violence in schools. In June, Jackson referred to that document — which was critical for this article — as a “list of shame
” that could soon be discontinued.
If the office limits or narrows its enforcement of Title IX, Kimmel said, victims may feel less empowered to report incidents because of a “chilling effect.” Requiring the “clear and convincing evidence” standard, she said, could make victims feel less empowered to report attacks if it’s harder to ensure their perpetrator is held accountable.
Christopher Perry, deputy executive director of Stop Abusive and Violent Environments, sees things differently. In a listening session with DeVos in July, Perry brought a college student who was accused of verbal sexual harassment and suspended without a hearing three weeks before graduation. But the accusation, Perry said, was fabricated. Although DeVos didn’t say during the meeting how she plans to proceed, Perry said he felt encouraged.
Perry said he hopes the department replaces the current guidance with procedures similar to recent recommendations
by an American Bar Association task force which, in some circumstances, seeks a higher standard of proof.
“What we’re trying to do is really put together a fair system that allows both parties to feel as though they were treated respectfully and that the outcome is reliable,” Perry said. “We want a full and fair investigation, we want both sides to be able to have adequate and timely notice of what’s going on, we would like a transparent hearing process, so realistically a lot of similar complaints you hear from victims, saying that schools may have dismissed their case out of hand without a full investigation.”
For that very reason — K-12 districts often fail to investigate complaints — changing the evidentiary standard may not have a huge effect on Beck’s work, she said, because she generally pursues justice through the courts. She currently has three pending cases, including against former Major League Baseball player Chad Curtis, who was found guilty
of sexually assaulting three teenage girls while working as a substitute teacher in Michigan. Any change to the department’s Title IX guidance, however, could have ramifications for K-12 schools.
“If the Department of Education even kind of takes its focus off of it, I can see that being very harmful to our nation’s students,” she said. “It’s really important, not only for schools to understand what their responsibilities are, but for students and parents to know what their rights are.”
Corrected August 9: This story was updated to clarify the number of Title IX sexual violence complaints the Office for Civil Rights resolved between 2009 and 2016. On both the K-12 and college level, the office resolved 371 sexual violence complaints.