Analysis: As Teacher Strikes and Grassroots Uprisings Give Way to a New Wave of Organized Rallies, Unions Look to Channel Educators’ Energy
Mike Antonucci’s Union Report appears most Wednesdays; see the full archive.
Last year at this time, we were all consumed by teacher strikes in places where such actions were highly unusual. In fact, they were technically illegal. They were even more noteworthy because they were mainly organized outside of the formal union structure.
Those 2018 strikes had another unexpected characteristic: They fit the common definition of a strike as an indefinite work stoppage.
Any work stoppage can be considered a strike, but most of us think of strikes as a union tactic designed to exert pressure on management to meet worker demands. The strike ends when the demands are met, a negotiated compromise is reached, or the union calls it off due to lack of progress or support.
None of us knew when the statewide West Virginia, Oklahoma and Arizona strikes would end. The same goes for the more traditional strikes that were held earlier this year in Denver, Los Angeles and Oakland as an outcome of failed collective bargaining.
While allowing for the possibility that major actions are being planned out of my sight, there are few indications that strikes similar to those in 2018 are imminent. What we are seeing instead is a spike in teacher union mass advocacy centered on increased school funding and limiting charter schools.
Only the North Carolina and Oregon rallies are scheduled during school hours, and Oregon is the only state where a walkout seems to be planned. So far, no one in authority has publicly suggested that any of these actions will be extended for more than one day.
A clamor arose in Mississippi when a Facebook group called “Pay Raise for Mississippi Teachers” discussed a walkout. The NEA-affiliated Mississippi Association of Educators followed up with an online survey in which it asked respondents about their willingness to perform a number of actions, including “walkout on a specific day and refuse to return for an indefinite amount of time.”
MAE President Joyce Helmick admitted the obvious to the Associated Press — that the phrase was a synonym for a strike. Teacher strikes are strictly prohibited in the state.
Legal ramifications didn’t stop teachers in red states last year, but MAE has a problem those groups didn’t have. It isn’t even the largest teacher organization in the state.
MAE has about 4,700 members, which constitutes about 15 percent of the state’s public school teachers. The Mississippi Professional Educators, which is not affiliated with any union, claims 14,000 members. It also has eight principles of belief, one of which is: “Students have the right to an uninterrupted education. Therefore, MPE will not participate in strikes, threats of strikes, walkouts, or other such actions.”
Whether there will be any further grassroots teacher “uprisings” remains to be seen. But for now, it appears the teacher unions are channeling that energy into ramped-up, but familiar, avenues of protest.
Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter